List

Reena R1, Jibi Paul2, Praveen Kumar3

Authors:
2Pofessor, Faculty of Physiotherapy, Dr.MGR. Deemed to be University, Chennai, Tamilnadu, India.
3Asst. Professor, Faculty of Physiotherapy, Dr.MGR. Deemed to be University, Chennai, Tamilnadu, India.
Corresponding Author:
1B.P.T. Graduate, Faculty of Physiotherapy, Dr.MGR. Deemed to be University, Chennai, Tamilnadu, India.
Mail id: reenamol193@gmail.com

ABSTRACT

Background of The Study: Hamstring is one of the commonest muscles often get tight as the biomechanics of hamstrings are complex because they pull over hip and knee joints. Stretching methods often define the development and improves body’s range of motion. Goal of all stretching relaxation is to provide joint mobility while maintaining joint stability. Hold relax is a technique of facilitating normal muscle sensation and muscle awareness. It is a relaxation technique to obtain lengthening reaction of muscle whose action is antagonist to movement limited in range. It is effective, simple and pain-free. PNF is used to supplement daily stretching and employed to quick gain in ROM, decreases in fatigue, prevent overuse injuries. The main objective of this study is to compare the effectiveness of passive stretching over PNF hold relax technique on hamstring tightness in young individuals.
Materials And Methods: 100 normal male and  female subjects were recruited for the study with age group of 18-25 yrs and divided into two groups. Group A (n=50) treated with passive stretching Group B (n=50) treated with hold relax PNF technique. Outcome measures of the study were Finger Tip to Floor test, Back Saver Sit and Reach test.
Result: The study shows there is statistical significant difference with P≤0.001 between Group A and B. When compare the two groups, Group B with PNF Hold relax gives more effective than the Group A with Passive stretching with Back Saver Sit and Reach test.
Conclusion: The study concluded that PNF Hold Relax technique showed greater improvement than Passive Stretching on hamstring flexibility .   

Key words: Hamstring flexibility, Passive stretching, PNF hold relax, Finger Tip to Floor test, Back Saver Sit and Reach test.

Received on 10 th February  2020, Revised on 19th February  2020, Accepted on 25th February 2020
DOI:10.36678/ijmaes.2020.v06i01.002

INTRODUCTION

Hamstring tightness is common in normal individual because of immobilization in a shortened position results in adaptive shortening. Tightness could make the musculo-tendinosus unit more susceptible to injury, increases resistance to anatomical structures, which may leads to overuse syndrome. Muscle tightness affects the normal length tension relationship. Muscle tightness also cause reciprocal inhibition 1.

The hamstring flexibility is defined as the ability to move a joint or series of joints through full, unrestricted, pain-free range of motion.    Flexibility is a key component for Prevention of injury and rehabilitation, stretching decreases injury and improves performance in sports for overall fitness. Increased flexibility: While stretching your hamstring can increase flexibility and improve your range of motion in your joints. Improved hamstring flexibility which will be able to perform everyday activity like climbing stairs, lifting or bending over with greater ease. Reduced hamstring muscle flexibility has been implicated in lumbar spine dysfunction, with number of studies showing positive correlation between decreased hamstrings, flexibility and low back pain 2, 3.

The hamstring muscle refers to those muscles that lie on the back of upper leg and thighs. They are strong muscles that can stretch up to 1.5 times their size, with regular stretching exercises.These muscles are used in almost all physical activity and keeping them stretched and goes a long way in improving overall flexibility and strength.Hamstring stretch are popular stretch used by gymnast, runners and sprinter to improve the flexibility of their muscles and to get ready with a warm up stretches with just the wall or a study chair for support loosen up tight muscles and improves blood flow to the lower limbs. Hamstring muscles make more flexible, preventing injury and tearing of the muscles 4.

Passive stretching: Passive stretching is also referred to as relaxed stretching. A passive stretch is a stretch where an individual will assume a position and hold it with the help of therapist/partner. The specificity of movement that a person performs in regular physical activity and stretching method often define the development and improve body’s range of motion. Goal of passive stretching programme is to provide joint mobility while maintaining joint stability.

PNF Technique: PNF is defined as exercises that enhance a neuro muscular response through the proprioceptors. Proprioceptive neuro- muscular facilitation is used as inhibition technique to assist with muscle elongation. PNF is used to supplement daily stretching when employed to quick gain in range of motion; it decreases fatigue and prevents overuse injuries. Hold relaxtechnique involves lengthening a tightened muscle and asks the patient to isometrically contract the muscle for several seconds. As the patient relaxes, after the contraction, the therapist lengthen the involved muscle further and holds the stretch at the end range of motion. Hold relax is a technique of facilitating normal muscle sensation and muscle awareness, used in treating hyper tonicity or motor dysfunction. It is often applied when there is muscle tightness in one side of joint and when immobility is the result of pain. PNF stretching was found to decrease muscle force in the hamstring muscles in response to the application of sudden stretch as might occur during functional activity.                          

Need of the study: Hamstring is one of the commonest muscles often get tight. The biomechanics of hamstrings is complex because they are two joints (hip & knee). Goal of passive stretching relaxation should be provided for joint mobility and maintaining joint stability.PNF Hold relax is a technique for facilitating normal muscle sensation, muscle awareness and decreases fatigue to prevent overuse injuries. The main aim of this study is to compare the effectiveness of passive stretching and PNF hold relax technique on hamstring tightness in young individuals. 

METHODOLOGY

This is an experimental study with Pre and Post Comparative test.  The study was conducted at Physiotherapy department, ACS Medical college and Hospital campus, Chennai. 100 normal subjects with age group of 18-25 yrs were recruited for the study and divided into two groups. Random sampling method used to allocate the samples in each group. Group A (n=50) treated with passive stretching Group B (n=50) treated with hold relax PNF technique. The study conducted for a duration of 2 months. Subjects with Recent fractures, Spinal deformity, TB spine, Psychological disorders were excluded from this study. Outcome measures of the study were Finger tip to floor test, Back saver sit and reach test.  Materials used for this study were informed concent, Inch tape, Scale, Couch Mark sheet.      

Intervention      

Finger -Tip- To Floor Test:  The patient stands comfortably with the feet facing forward and is asked to bend forward. The instruction is to bend  forward without  bending their  knees, attempt to touch the floor with your fingertips, go only as far as you can”.

Distance between the patient long finger and the floor is measured in inches. The process is performed once, the best effort is measured.

Back saver sit and reach test: The variations of the traditional sit and reach test is to measure the flexibility of the left and right legs separately.  This is the procedure used for the Fitness Gram Program.                This test measures the flexibility of the lower limb and hamstring muscles. Back Saver Sit And Reach Test is extremely high 5,6.                                             

Fig. 1 Finger tip to floor test

Group A: passive stretching.

Procedure: The patient in supine position. The therapist  should  kneel  down  on  the  mat  and  place the patients  heel    against  own  shoulder  and  placed  both  hands  along  the  anterior  aspect  of  distant  thigh  to  keep  knee  extended,  opposite  extremity  is  stabilized  in  extension  position  and  therapist  knee  place  by  with  in  0 degree  extension,  hip  in  neutral  position  and  then  investigator  flexes  the  hip  as  far  as possible. The stretching duration for 30 seconds.

Group B: PNF hold relax technique.  

Procedure: The patient in supine lying position.  For  each  stretching, therapist  give  passive  stretching  until  the patient  reports  mild  stretching  sensation  and  hold  that  position  for 30 seconds  by  asking     his / her  leg to push  back  towards   against  resistance  of therapist shoulder,  after  contraction and relaxation  for  30  seconds, measurement should be taken. 

Fig .2 Passive Stretching
Fig.3 PNF Hold Relax technique

RESULT

In Table 1 with group a, ftf and bssr have significant difference between the pre test & post test (p≤ 0.001).

Table 1 Comparison of FTF and BSSR in group a between pre and post test
Graph 1. Comparison of FTF and BSSR in Group A between Pre and Post test.
Table 2 Comparison of FTF and BSSR in Group B between Pre And Post Test                                 

In table 2  with Group B, FTF and BSSR have significant difference between the pre & post test value (P≤0.001).

Graph 2. Comparison of FTF and BSSR in Group B between Pre and Post test
Table  3. Comparison of FTF between Group A And B in Pre And Post Test

This table shows that there is no significant difference in the pre test value between Group A and Group B (P≥0.05). This table shows that there is no significant difference in the post test value between Group A and Group B (P≥0.05).

Graph 3. Comparison of FTF between Group A and B In Pre and Post test.
Table 4 Comparison of bssr between group a and b in pre and post test

This table shows that there is no significant difference in the pre test values in the score between Group A and B. This table shows statistically significant difference in post test values in BSSR score between Group A & Group B (p≤0.001).

Graph 4. Comparison of bssr between group a and b in pre and post test.

DISCUSSION

The present study compared the effectiveness of passive stretching and PNF Hold Relax technique on hamstring tightness in young individuals. In this study suggested that Group B [PNF Hold Relax technique] showed greater improvement than Group A .

There is another study which shows there is no significant difference in ROM in standing & supine hamstring stretching as they are equally effective conducted by “Decoster LC (2004) 7,8.

In Table 1,it shows significant increase in post test mean value of Group A [passive stretching] which has more effective mean value than pre test. In table-1 shows statistically highly significant difference in BSSR & FTF between pre test and post test (p ≤ 0.001).

In Table 2 shows significant increase in post test value of BSSR compare to FTF in Group B [PNF Hold Relax technique]. The pre test reduces compared to post test in BSSR of Group B shows significant between pre and post test (p ≤ 0.001).

In Table 3 shows effective increases in Group B compared to Group A, but it shows a negative pattern between pre and post test. Sharman Malanie who found that propioceptive neuromuscular facilitation produces superior ROM 9,10,11.

 In Table 4 shows significant increases in Group B compared to Group A (P≤0.005). Therefore the use of PNF hold relax technique in Group B (p≤0.001) shows greater effective than Group A which will reduces the hamstring tightness.

A number of studies have demonstrated that stretching muscle tissue can increase joint range of motion 12,13,14.

Ethical Clearance: Ethical clearance has obtained from Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR.MGR Educational and Reasearch Institute, Chennai to conduct this study with reference number: 025/ PHSIO/ IRB/2016dated 06/02/2016.

Conflict of interest: There was no conflict of interest to conduct this study.

Fund for the study: It was aself financed study.

CONCLUSION

The result suggested that PNF Hold Relax technique showed greater improvement   than Passive Stretching. This study reveals that there is a significant difference between passive stretching and PNF Hold Relax technique. In the end of this study, PNF Hold Relax Technique is found to be more effective and reduces the tightness of hamstring muscles compared to passive stretching groups.

Limitation of the Study: The sample size of this study was small.   

Recommendation of the Study:  This study can conduct with different age groups. The sample size can be increased in upcoming studies. Different outcome measures recommended.

REFERENCES

  1. Carter, AM :Kinzey, ss, chitwood, LF, et al : (2009). PNF decreases muscle activity during the stretch reflex in selected posterior thigh muscles.  Jo sports Rehabilitation  :9 (4) 249-278.
  2. Spernoga SG, Uhl TL. (2001). Duration maintained hamstrings flexibility after one time, modified hold relax stretching protocol. Journal of Athletic Training, 6:44-48.
  3. Yogeeta SK. (2010). Effectiveness of passive stretching vs hold relax technique in flexibility of hamstring muscle. J. Health Allied Science, 9 (3); 13.
  4. Corbin C B Noble, (1980). Flexibility-A major component of physical fitness, Journal of Physical Education, 51-57.
  5. Hui S.S., Yuen P.Y. (2000) Validity of the modified back-saver sit-and-reach test: a comparison with other protocols. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 32, 1655-1659.
  6. Hui S.C., Yuen P.Y., Morrow J.R. Jr, Jackson A.W. (1999) Comparison of the criterion-related validity of sit-and-reach tests with and without limb length adjustment in Asian adults. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 70, 401-406 
  7. Decoster L C. (2004). Standing & supine hamstring stretching are equally effective. Journal of Athletic training 39(4); 330-334.
  8. Len Karvitz, P.H.D., (2000). Vivian H Heyward, Flexibility Training Journal of Fitness Training, 7:18-20.
  9. Worrell, T., T. Smith, and J. Winegardner. (1994). Effects of hamstring stretching on hamstring muscle performance. JOSPT 20: 154-159.
  10. Ross, M. (1999). Effects of lower extremity position & stretching on hamstring muscle flexibility. J. strength cond., Res. 13: 124-129.
  11. Tanigawa MC. (1972). Comparison of the hold-relax procedure and passive mobilization on increasing muscle length phys. Ther., 7; 725-35.
  12. Malanie S. (2006). PNF stretching mechanism & clinical implication. Journal of sports medicine 36(11) : 929-939.
  13. Malanie S. (2006). Proprioceptive neuro-muscular facilitation stretching Mechanism and clinical implication. Journal of Sports Medicine, 36(11): 929-939.
  14. Worrell TW, Smith TL et al. (1994). Effect of hamstring stretching on hamstring muscle performance. Journal of Orthopaedic Sports, 20(3):154-159.

Citation:  

Reena R, Jibi Paul, Praveen Kumar (2020). To compare the effectiveness of passive stretching versus pnf hold relax technique on hamstring tightness in young individuals  , International Journal of Medical and Exercise Science; 6 (1); 669-675.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  Posts

1 6 7 8
June 10th, 2019

Comparative study between static stretching and dynamic stretching on mechanical neck pain

JIBI PAUL1 , THENMOZHI S 2 Authors: 2 BPT Intern, Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR.MGR.Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, Chennai,India Corresponding […]

June 10th, 2019

Efficacy of selective trunk activity in improving trunk control in hemiplegic patients

MANJUNATHA. H 1 ,JIBI PAUL 2 ,MADAN MOHAN.M.R3 Corresponding Author: 1 Principal, East Point College of Physiotherapy, Jnana Prabha, Bidarahalli, […]

June 10th, 2019

An Analysis on the effect of Buteyko Breathing and relaxed postures over the chest exapnsion of asthmatic collegiate population- An experimental study

S. GLADIES KAMALAM1 , G. SRIVIDYA2 , J. ANDREWS MILTON3 Corresponding Author: 1 Associate Professor, Bethany Navajeevan College of Physiotherapy, […]

June 10th, 2019

An analytical study of Vo2 Max, resting heart rate, waist hip ratio and flexibility changes on combined effects of dynamic core stability exercises and stretching in middle aged overweight men population in Chennai

RADHAKRISHNAN. R1 , VENKATESAN. R 2 , KIRAN.V3 , SENTHIL. P4 , SHARMILA. K5 Corresponding Author: 1 Research scholar, Tamilnadu […]

June 10th, 2019

Impact of exercising with Acapella on peak expiratory flow rate of chronic asthmatics

S.SATHYA 1 , K.ANISH FATHIMA 2 , JIBI PAUL3 Authors: 1,3Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR MGR Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, […]

March 10th, 2019

Effect of Otago Exercise Program (OEP) and Strength Training Program (STP) on leg strength and risk of fall among bilateral knee osteoarthritis patients

KANCHAN A. KATRE1 , VIJAYAKUMAR PUSHPARAJ 2 , JIBI PAUL3 Authors: 1 Faculty of Physiotherapy, P.E.S Modern college of Physiotherapy, […]

March 10th, 2019

Comparative analysis of self image on body shape among obese college students and employees of corporate sector

D. PAUL NICOLUAS1 , JIBI PAUL2 Author: 2 Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR MGR Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, Chennai,India Corresponding […]

March 10th, 2019

Night shift and its effect on the health of working women in BPO Chennai

DIVYA B1*, ANDREW MICHAEL2, JIBI PAUL1 Authors: 1 Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR MGR Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, Chennai,India 2 […]

March 10th, 2019

Effects of muscle energy techniques on knee joint mobilization in an early stage following fracture

Moorthy A 1*, Jibi Paul 1, G. Muthuraj 1 Authors:1 Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR MGR Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, […]

December 10th, 2018

Changes in eating habits among youth: A study on college students in Chennai City

LEENA VS1* , LAZAR.S2 , JIBI PAUL1 Authors: 1 Faculty of Physiotherapy, DR MGR Educational and Research Institute, Velappanchavadi, Chennai […]